First, let me say that like my other trip to the Yucatan (Mayan Palace - Riveria Maya), I personally did not choose the hotel. Although we were not RCI members, we were considered RCI because of the connection my friend's mother has being a pilot for a major airline - we got a great deal on the price.
Now, let me say a few things upfront. This is the only time I had stayed in an all-inclusive. Second, my only comparison was Mayan Palace - which felt like a 5 star resort - and I had an amazing trip there. So perhaps I am biased. Third, when we made the reservations (4 ladies in our mid twenties on a getaway trip) we were under the impression that we would also be able to visit the sister resort, Temptation, for free. Between the time we reserved and our arrival, that had changed. Blue Bay caters to families and Temptation is adults only - In retrospect we would have preferred to have stayed at the other resort. The day pass to get in was upwards of $60... no thanks.
The resort staff was SUPER friendly and they were the best part of our stay. They learned our names immediately and were really great. We had a fun experience with the evening activities and the staff was incredibly talented, comedic and entertaining. They do evening "shows" in their theatre - We found the Pirates and Lion King Shows to be entertaining - probably because we also love Disney. I don't know that "spring breakers" would be at all interested in the shows, but families with children up to about 12 or 13 (teens would yawn!) would really appreciate them.
The first morning, we went on the "tour" for the timeshare in order to get free spa coupons. We ate breakfast with an attractive guy who spent the whole time flirting with us and trying to close his sale. The bloody marys we were being served (we hardly finished one before another arrived, many times over) were a clever tactic on their part to attempt to loosen us up to the prospect of buying. Like I said we just wanted spa coupons and frankly the on the beach massages we got with them? Totally worth it!
The other two things we did was to pay the Premium nightclub cost to go out to Senor Frogs which included transportation there and unlimited drinks (worth it) and the catamaran trip with the spinaker (again, very worth it). We went on one of the booze boats for the catamaran - Half the boat was topless on the way back and it was definately NOT a buttoned up trip. Only go if you know what you are getting yourself into (we did, and it was awesome!). The snorkeling was not fabulous - we actually spent our last day at the resort going on a cheap tiny boat from the guys at the hotel and saw much better reefs for about $35 us a piece.
Speaking of drinks though - Those bloody marys we got on the TS tour were literally the ONLY full strength drink we had in the entire week we stayed there. We tried everything - The only solution was to drink beer which of course immediately got warm due to the temperature. Even the RED WINE had been watered down (so gross! and I love wine!) The Oysters (sp? on the name) restaraunt was eh - everything was over salted. I think we ate there only twice even though we had been given enough to have eaten there 4 or 5 times. The buffet food that is served as the all inclusive is the same...every...single...day. No variety. None. You eat cactus on day one - you eat the same dish, served the same way, day seven. I was not a fan of the food whatsoever.
There were 4 of us ladies and due to being RCI guests, we were given rooms on the ocean side, first floor. We had three side by side rooms which connected to each other, four beds, three bathrooms, and the center room was a full kitchen, pull out couch, full dining area and television. VERY spacious accomodations! The only downside of the rooms that I found were that they were dated (decor) and the bathrooms were subpar (we had problems with hot water a couple days).
As many others will say - If you stay here and cannot get a room on the ocean side, you will not be pleased. There is a HUGE HUGE difference in accomdations between the two.
Again, perhap it is always this way at all-inclusive resorts (sub par foods, bad drinks) but if it is I can't imagine why people stay at them. I wouldn't stay at Blue Bay again unless I was looking for a very inexpensive, family friendly place to get away.
TripAdvisor has free and easy resources to help you enhance your listing and promote your property.
- Start Here - Visit Your Owners' Center
- Add Photo
- Add Video


